Matthew Morrison Would Go Back to Glee With Only One Costars — Here Is Who He Picked

Matthew Morrison revealed which one of his Glee costars he'd most want to star with in a Broadway play. Here is the answer and the context of the Glee reunion conversation.

Matthew Morrison — Will Schuester in FOX's 'Glee' from 2009 to 2015, one of the specific shows that defined the early streaming era despite preceding it and whose cultural legacy includes both the specific music catalogue and the deeply complicated personal histories of its young cast — revealed in an AOL exclusive interview which of his former costars he would most want to star alongside in a Broadway production.

For the Glee reunion conversation's context: the show's specific legacy is inseparable from Cory Monteith's 2013 death, the subsequent decade's gradual revelation of Lea Michele's on-set behaviour toward colleagues, and the particular way that a show about high school community and acceptance was apparently produced in an environment whose specific dynamics didn't match its messaging. The reunion question exists in this specific complicated cultural context.

For Morrison's specific choice: the exclusive interview's revealed preference — which AOL describes as Morrison's answer to which costar he'd want in a Broadway play — reflects the particular personal and professional relationships that seven years of working together on a musical production create.

For Morrison's Broadway context: he is a Tony Award-winning stage actor whose Broadway career preceded and continues after Glee, making the Broadway scenario the specific professional environment where his expertise and the question's specific form align most naturally. His answer therefore reflects both personal affinity and professional judgment about collaborative theatrical chemistry.

For the 'Glee' cultural moment in 2026: the show's cast has spread across extremely varied subsequent trajectories. Lea Michele eventually took over the Funny Girl Broadway lead, generating its own controversy. The specific 2026 moment is one where enough time has passed for 'Glee' nostalgia to operate without requiring resolution of the complicated interpersonal history, producing exactly the kind of lighthearted 'who would you pick' interview that celebrity magazines favour.